| 
 Why / Cry For A Shadow 
MGM K13227, March 27, 1964  
 
  
     
  | 
    Why 
    Written by  Tony Sheridan, with Bill Crompton 
    Sung by Tony Sheridan 
    Vocal Harmonies by John, Paul, and George 
    Engineer: Karl Hinze 
     
    Cry For A Shadow 
    Written by George and John 
    Instrumental 
    Engineer: Karl Hinze  | 
   
 
Why 
History 
Why, or more completely Why (Can't You Love Me Again), was recorded during the same
Polydor sessions that produced My Bonnie.  These sessions
were held in Germany on June 22 and 23, 1961, with the Beatles performing as backup
musicians for Tony Sheridan.   This time, however, John, Paul and George can be heard
performing the vocal harmonies. 
US Releases 
  
    March 27, 1964 
    February 3, 1964 
    March 1964 
    October 5, 1964 
    August 15, 1966 
    May 4, 1970 
    1982 
    1982 
    1983 | 
    MGM K13227 
    The Beatles, with Tony Sheridan and their Guests, MGM E-4215 
    Savage Young Beatles, Savage BM-69 
    Ain't She Sweet, Atco 33-169 
    This Is Where It Started, Metro M-563 
    In The Beginning, Polydor 24-2504 
    First Movement, Audio Fidelity PHX 339 
    Collectables 1524 
    20 Hits, The Beatles, Phoenix 20 P20-623 | 
   
 
Highest US Chart Position 
April 11, 1964 at #88 
Cry For A Shadow 
History 
This instrumental track was also recorded at Hamburg's Friedrich
Ebert Halle school in June 1961.  This became the first Beatle composition ever
to appear on record, when released in France on Tony Sheridan's "Mr. Twist"
EP.  It was mostly George's song, but with John's help.  Originally titled
'Beatle Bop', Cry For A Shadow was a parody of the Shadows' 'Frightened City.' 
US Releases 
  
    March 27, 1964 
    February 3, 1964 
    March 1964 
    October 5, 1964 
    August 15, 1966 
    May 4, 1970 
    1982 
    1982 
    1983 
    November 25, 1995 | 
    MGM K13227 
    The Beatles, with Tony Sheridan and their Guests, MGM E-4215 
    Savage Young Beatles, Savage BM-69 
    Ain't She Sweet, Atco 33-169 
    This Is Where It Started, Metro M-563 
    In The Beginning, Polydor 24-2504 
    First Movement, Audio Fidelity PHX 339 
    Collectables 1520 
    20 Hits, The Beatles, Phoenix 20 P20-623 
    Anthology I, Apple 34445 | 
   
 
Live Performances 
  
    | 1961 | 
   
  
    | Performed throughout England in 1961 | 
   
 
  |